I gave the same prompt to 3 AI app builders

BUILD LOG
Written By Ailsa Zircher

I gave the same one shot prompt to three AI app builders.

Not multiple iterations. Not refinement. Just one detailed prompt for a personal workspace app. The UX they produced was actually quite similar.

But the difference was in how far each got me:

  • Lovable — felt like a usable product. Coherent UX, working flows, strong responsiveness.

  • Figma Make — solid prototype. Same structure, but would need more work to feel polished.

  • Google Stitch — a design starting point. Good exploration, but missing pieces and consistency.

View Results

The Takeaway:

it's not just about what gets generated, it's about how much effort is still required after the first prompt. Same input, very different distance to "done."

Ailsa Zircher
Previous

The problem with helpful AI
Next

I spent half a day trying to set up a way to stay updated on SaaS